Page 32 - BOSS Today Issue 25
P. 32

HR











       OVERTIME &






       HOLIDAY PAY:






       THE END OF






       THE ROAD?










       On 4 November 2014 the long-awaited decision of the Employment Appeal

       Tribunal (EAT) in the case of Bear Scotland v Fulton & Others was released.



          he Tribunal had to decide                                                      to the 20 days holiday covered
       Twhether non-guaranteed                                                           by the Working Time Directive.
       overtime (that is, overtime                                                       Any holidays above that can
       which the employer does not                                                       be treated as normal. Finally, it
       have to offer, but the employee                                                   would be worth contacting your
       must work if offered) should                                                      local BOSS HR Adviser if you
       be included when calculating                                                      need continued support on this
       holiday pay. The question rested                                                  issue.
       on whether such overtime                                                            Whilst waiting to see the
       was ‘intrinsically linked’ to their                                               outcome of any appeal,
       performance and remuneration,                                                     members may want to review
       as described in 2012 by the                                                       current overtime rates – could
       European Court of Justice in the                                                  you reduce the amount of
       case of British Airways v Williams.   complicated systems to keep   representatives knocking on   overtime done? Also, initiate a
       The EAT’s answer was that yes,   track of each individual’s pay   their doors over the coming   general audit on holiday pay
       it was intrinsically linked, and   over each 12-week period.  weeks wanting to open   levels, as well as calculate the
       should be included. By way of   However, some comfort can   negotiations. What should their   effect of having to include
       contrast, items such as expenses   be drawn from the fact that   response be?     voluntary overtime in the
       are not intrinsically linked.  the EAT severely restricted any   Firstly, point out to the   future. After all, forewarned is
         The howls of pain that   backdating exercise. There were   representatives that this decision   forearmed!
       greeted this decision are   fears that claims for back pay   may well be appealed, possibly
       understandable. It means   may run all the way back to   all the way up to Europe, in   n FOR FURTHER ADVICE
       that any employer who bases   1998, but the EAT has in fact   which case any final decision   ON THIS SUBJECT, PLEASE
       holiday pay purely on basic   restricted it to a maximum of   on the matter is probably years   CONTACT THE BOSS HR
       pay may have to update     three months.               away. Secondly, bear in mind   TEAM ON 0845 450 1565.
       those calculations and install   Employers may find employee   that this decision only relates

       32  BOSS TODAY | December 2014/January 2015


   DTB1.indd   2                                                                                             09/12/2014   11:48
   27   28   29   30   31   32   33   34   35   36